So I was at a college party, not the college that I attend, and a few of my buddies introduce me to a few of their female friends. Unfortunately I already had maybe one too many drinks but I stared at the first girl with a shocked face, and I used the "hey I know you" opener, which when I think about it now wasn't really necessary because of the mutual connection amongst friends.
It was going fine until my scrambled brain decided to say "Yeah, you look like one of my good friends but smaller and rounder."
She started laughing and backing away while saying "Wowww, you called me fat!" it seemed like she took it as a joke and was a good sport about it because she joked about my abrasiveness throughout the night. I tried saving it by doing the cube trick which she was getting really into it, but eventually we got separated and I couldn't finish the cube story.
The last I saw of her was when she was dancing with some guy and she called me out jokingly one last time about calling her fat and I said in her ear, "We have to finish the story, I could tell you everything about yourself in 5 minutes just from that story" then she gives me a face of shock and curiosity, but I walked away after.
Part of me says that I should have just taken her hand and told the guy "Hey let me borrow her real quick, I'll be back with her I promise" or something like that but my buddies and I were basically crashing a frat party at a different school so I didn't want it getting ugly.
What do you guys think I should have done?