So I had this girl over last night that I'm actually growing to like. Well one thing led to another and we ended up having hooking up. I was getting her warmed up with some fingering, and one thing led to another. When all was said and done she told me that she was bleeding. I asked if it was her period, she said no. She's totally not a virgin, and my nails were trimmed.
We were being a bit rough but nothing too extreme. I google searched around and I got the same answers of period, virgin, and trimmed nails.
This also isn't the first time that it has happened to me with different girls. Am I doing something wrong?