So I've come up with an opener that's getting me about a 75% success rate. I'm not going to share the whole thing here until it is completely played out in my market (I've had people steal from me before and completely ruin it).
Basically after the girl responds I need to follow up with a funny/cheesy pickup line or a sincere message about why the girl is a good match for me.
I've got plenty of pickup lines so that's not the issue. I haven't been getting responses on my "sincere" messages though. Does anyone have any pointers on how to come across as sincere in an online message?